On 14 August 2023, Mr Kristopher Bloomfield was stopped at Birmingham International Airport carrying a rucksack containing two knives. Police subsequently searched his home and discovered ammunition and three types of military-issue explosives. At the Plea and Trial Preparation Hearing, Mr Bloomfield entered guilty pleas to some offences on the indictment, and the three counts relating to the explosives were ordered to be left to lie on the file. One month later, the prosecution successfully applied to reinstate these three offences, stating that there had been a misunderstanding between counsel and the CPS in relation to these offences. Mr Bloomfield was subsequently convicted after trial on these three counts.
The appeal raised an important question of criminal procedure concerning the circumstances in which the prosecution may seek to reinstate charges previously ordered to lie on the file.
The Court of Appeal clarified that a significant change of circumstances is not a mandatory prerequisite for reinstatement. Instead, the governing test is whether reinstatement is in the interests of justice, taking account of factors including finality, fairness, prejudice to the defendant and the public interest.
Stephen Rose KC and Hannah Wilson represented the appellant in R v Bloomfield [2026] EWCA 1441. The appeal was heard by the Lady Chief Justice sitting with Mr Justice Wall and HHJ Shaun Smith KC.
Although dismissing the appeal, the court emphasised that applications to reinstate charges should be rare and subject to close scrutiny. The judgment provides important guidance for criminal practitioners on the finality of court orders and the circumstances in which the prosecution may proceed in relation to counts left to lie on the file.
Read Judgment here: Kristopher Bloomfield v R-[2026] EWCA Crim 1441
Stephen Rose KC prosecutes and defends in serious crime and is regularly instructed on behalf of appellants and respondents in the Court of Appeal.
Hannah Wilson enjoys a busy practice as both a junior alone and a led junior in all areas of criminal law.


